The Phantom Writers is Back From The Dead
We were completely offline from the early morning of May 1st 2009 to the afternoon of May 16th, 2009.
The reason we were brought down is completely documented on third-party news websites, most notably Domain Name Wire.
Our domain registrar was Parava Networks, located at 10-domains.com. Parava it seems was in violation of its contract with ICANN, which led to ICANN pulling Parava Networks accreditation on April 9th.
This prevented us from being able to update our DNS server data, after our server migration in April of 2009.
Before this started, I had about a dozen gray hairs. I swear that during the last two weeks, I had hundreds of hairs go gray…
It was frustrating. Everything was primed for the move, except I could not update my DNS server IP settings.
More than three dozen websites that I own and manage went offline, and I could not find a way to get them back online. Parava Networks referred me to ICANN every time I tried to get support. ICANN referred me back to Parava Networks for support. And round and round it went. After about the fourth pass of completing the circle, I gave up on a quick fix.
So on May 5th, I launched mirror domains for The Phantom Writers and Links And Traffic, at http://www.thephantomwriters.org/ and http://www.backlinksandtraffic.com/
I put out press releases noting the existence of the mirror websites for my customers who were looking for me. But, press release or not, not everyone went to Google to try to locate me when my website came up dead.
Bounced emails, led to customer chargebacks, because they assumed I had gone out of business. I can’t blame them for thinking that I had gone out of business, although I was trying to let everyone know what happened.
My press release for thephantomwriters.com was ranked #5 in google for my domain name by May 8th. My press release regarding the absense of linksandtraffic.com was ranked #3 in google for the domain name by May 9th.
On May 10th, I sent out a mailing to all of my customers, whose email address is already recorded in our database. That email was issued through our mirror domain at thephantomwriters.org
Most people understood the nature of the situation. But I did receive one angry phone call from a fellow on May 11th, who insisted that I was lying about the situation and that it was obvious that I simply had not paid my bills. He criticized me for more than ten minutes about how I should just pay my bill and get back to providing my services. Wow! What can you tell a guy like that?
Over the course of our first down week, I went through the website to fix all links that I had hard-coded to resolved to thephantomwriters.com. I had all of the links cleansed by the weekend of the 10th, to enable anyone navigating my website from thephantomwriters.org to be able to reach any page they wanted to reach.
During the week of May 10-16, I worked to duplicate my email subscriptions on a safe .org email address, so that I could resume my article distribution service, in the event that I could not get the dot com back online. That took a lot longer than I had anticipated. After three 14-hour days, and several five- or six-hour days - just on this task - I still have not completed the process, although I am about 80% complete for the .org email address to be able to continue services in the event of another .com downtime.
I received my first bit of good news on May 12th. ICANN decided to push all of the 36,000 domains that were registered at Parava Networks to Hover, which is a domain name registration reseller for Tucows.com.
On May 13th, I received more news that the process of migration had started.
Of course, I was one of those people caught outside the normal process… because I was not able to update my whois records before the move to Hover. Silly me, I had put all of my whois info pointing to an email address at thephantomwriters.com, which was down at the time, due to its incorrect DNS data.
Those domain holders who had correct email information were moved on May 13th and 14th.
Those of us who did not receive service on May 13th and 14th were told to contact Hover directly on May 15th. I contacted the support email address Friday morning at 6am, and I was finally able to speak with the customer support manager on the evening of May 15th. I finally had access to a domain registrar account, that actually permitted me to make service updates. Yipee!
On the afternoon of May 16th, the whois data finally proporgated through the system, bringing all three dozen of my websites back online.
We lost 16 days of revenue from our websites. We also lost further.
Domain News Wire announced on May 15th that Parava Network customers were noticing that they had been cheated - the extra years they had purchased on their domains were not in the whois records, once their websites were transitioned to Hover.
I have not yet done a full accounting, but I was cheated by Parava Networks also. All of the websites that I make real money with had been registered to at least 2010. But when I got into my Hover account, all of my primary domains are coming due in the next four months!
Thank God I did not buy years in advance!
I also know that I lost control of one domain altogether. Although I had paid for it since 2006, only the 10-domains whois reflected that ownership. It was not a primary domain, but one that I had held for future use. So the loss of it is merely irritating. When I went to ICANN regarding this domain which has since been sold to another party, ICANN recommended that I should either sue Parava Networks for my loss, or I should try to buy back the domain from the current holder of the domain.
Terrible solutions both. ICANN pulled Parava’s accreditation, because Parava was not paying the domain registration fees to ICANN. So what makes ICANN believe that my suing Parava would accomplish anything more than me wasting attorney’s fees to get a judgement that could never be collected. And the current domain name holder wants $450 for the domain - it is just not worth it at this point.
Someone had suggested that this is what I get for utilizing a no-name domain registrar. But I was not the highest-tier customer doing business with Parava Networks. The following websites were also part of the Parava Networks portfolio:
My thought is that if some of the big boys can get caught by a rogue domain registrar, then I should not feel bad for having been ensnared by the same web of deceit, as delivered by Parava Netwoks.
It was noted during this process that even the snail mail address of Parava Networks from its whois, came back as “address not found”. Wow!
Lessons Learned…
* Never again will I keep all of my whois records in one location.
* Never again will I rely only on two Domain Name Servers. When I look at domain registrars, an integral requirement of my using them will be that I can have four domain name servers attached to a domain, then I will have all four filled, two pointing at one dns server and the other two pointing at another dns server. (This has not yet been implemented, but it is on my agenda of “things to do”.)
* Never again will I rely on only one doorway for my primary websites… I am keeping thephantomwriters.org and backlinksandtraffic.com online. Both of these sites will eventually present a different view of the primary domains, then both will receive their own linking and promotion. Think of them as Split A-B testing at the domain level.
* I will always keep my domain name registrar and webhosting company names in my Google alerts, so that I can see problems before they blow up. If I had Parava Networks in my google alerts, I could have prevented this mess, since the warning letters to Parava by ICANN were documented in early March, and other people pointed of the DNS errors in the Parava Networks whois database at least six months in advance of ICANN pulling the plug on Parava Networks. This nightmare was preventable, had I simply added my domain registrar to my Google Alerts list.
.
I am glad to finally be back, operating where people have come to expect to find me.
.
Bill Platt - owner of thephantomwriters.com and linksandtraffic.com
.
Follow Us On Twitter:
@contentmanager - Bill’s personal twitter account about all things marketing.
@phantomwriters - News from The Phantom Writers website.






































